The Scotch-Irish have had a prominent role in American and British history. Originating in Scotland and the border regions of Northern England, this ethnic group migrated to Northern Ireland in the 17th Century. Many subsequently then came to America in various waves, often settling in rural areas and being a driving force in American expansion in the 18th and 19th Centuries. The migration of the Scotch-Irish from Pennsylvania through the Appalachians to Tennessee and subsequently Texas helped drive much of the United States’ growth as they drove Native American populations out of the areas they settled.
In Hard Neighbors: The Scotch-Irish Invasion of North America and the Making of an American Identity, author Colin G. Calloway explores the history of the Scotch-Irish through the late 19th Century. This immigrant group was often marginalized by leaders in the colonies and early United States for its rural and uncivilized behavior. Their behavior was also often violent, such as in the Paxton Massacre of 1763 and the Whiskey Rebellion in the mid 1790’s. Hating both established governments (for not protecting them and their interests) and “the other” (Native Americans, mostly, in the early days of the country), the Scotch-Irish became an insular, often resentful, demographic in the United States. Several of them became battle-tested veterans of the War of 1812 and one of them, Andrew Jackson, became their voice and was elected President in 1828 and 1832. Jackson’s policies towards Native Americans were the culmination of Scotch-Irish desires put into official government action. Despite these actions, some Scotch-Irish and Native Americans co-existed peacefully and intermarried. Like any history of a country (and many family stories), the reality and story can be complicated.
Calloway’s book is a fair, even assessment of a group of people who shaped much of American history despite not often being in the leading role of it.
MY RATING: 4.5